HomeNews & TopicsHealth Care PolicyAdvance care planning for patients with chronic illnesses

Advance care planning for patients with chronic illnesses

Published on

The movement officially began in 1990 following the landmark case of Nancy Cruzan in the United States. The lengthy court battle over her life-sustaining treatment fuelled advocacy for the use of advance directives. The thought was that widespread use of advance directives would prevent such lengthy battles over treatment.

The reality, however, is that advance directives are nowhere near the panacea people thought they would be. Twenty-five years later the use of advance directives remains quite low: only 10-15 per cent of the general population have completed such documents. And experience has revealed a host of problems with their implementation, one of which is that the documents are rarely accessible when they are needed most.

Additionally, the recent media attention over the Margot Bentley case in B.C. has caused many people to ask, “What’s the point?” Ms. Bentley actually had completed an advance directive, which her family tried to implement, but the courts have ruled that the nursing home where she resides is actually obligated to feed her – in direct contradiction to her previous wishes.

MORE: SOLVING THE MYSTERIES OF HEART SURGERY

While there are a host of problems with advance directives, those problems simply highlight the flaws with relying solely on documents. Advance care planning is about much more than written advance directives – in fact, one can engage in advance care planning without ever completing an advance directive document. Advance care planning is a process of reflection and dialogue about what is important to you and how you want health care decisions made for you when you can no longer make those decisions yourself. While the process of advance care planning can be awkward and uncomfortable for many people, there are several reasons why it is an important and worthwhile process – especially for patients with chronic illnesses.

One reason is that while most of us would prefer to die comfortably at home, odds are that few of us will actually get to die this way. Recent statistics suggest that 70% of Canadians will die in hospital, and 10-15 per cent of those will experience an admission to an intensive care unit during their last hospital visit. If this is not the kind of death you want, especially the ICU part of it, advance care planning can help you avoid it.

MORE: UNDERSTANDING DIABETES

Second, many people avoid advance care planning because they trust their loved ones to know their wishes and make the right decisions. The problem is, studies show your loved ones aren’t very good at predicting what you would want! A recent meta-analysis of these studies concluded an accuracy rate of about 68 per cent. That means for anyone trusting their loved ones to make the decision they would make, only two-thirds of them will get it right.

Third, and perhaps most importantly, the process of having to make end-of-life decisions on behalf of a loved one is an extremely stressful and emotionally difficult experience. A 2011 study of surrogate decision makers found many of them experienced symptoms such as anxiety and depression, symptoms which they carried with them long after the hospital experience ended. But one of the important findings of the study was that knowledge of the patient’s wishes was one of the factors that reduced the psychological and emotional impact on surrogate decision makers.

The most important part of the advance care planning process is the dialogue with your loved ones, especially those who will be making decisions on your behalf. The dialogue will help them understand what is important to you and will give them guidance if and when the time comes to make difficult decisions on your behalf. If you’re not going to do it for yourself, at least do it for them.

Latest articles

New technology enhances cardiac care

Humber River Health recognizes that modern challenges are best met with modern solutions, and...

IPAC Canada Develops Essential New Course to Support Long-Term Care Infection Prevention and Control Leads

Infection Prevention and Control Canada (IPAC Canada) is launching a comprehensive training program tailored...

New technology for advancing inclusive, equitable care

An imaging device developed by an Ontario start-up company is being studied at Hamilton...

World-first trial shows benefits of finding, treating undiagnosed asthma and COPD

It’s estimated that 70 per cent of people with asthma or COPD go undiagnosed....

More like this

Understanding the environmental impact of hospital pharmacy supply chains

The pharmacy sector produces a range of environmental effects, encompassing greenhouse gas emissions, ecological...

Collaborating internationally to better protect patients from superbugs

Surrey Memorial Hospital is one of 12 hospitals around the globe involved in a...

New program tackles wait-list, brings surgeries closer to home

A new initiative brings day surgery closer to eastern Ontario families, supported by the...

Sounding the alarm for a sustainable Canadian cancer preparedness plan

Cancer remains the leading cause of death in Canada. An estimated two in five...

First Nations patients leave ED without completing treatment more than comparable non–First Nations patients

First Nations patients in Alberta leave emergency departments (EDs) without completing treatment more often...

Verspeeten Family Cancer Centre Unveiling Marks a Historic Milestone in Cancer Research and Treatment

London, Ontario: London Health Sciences Foundation (LHSF) is proud to announce the unveiling of...